I came across the following item as I was surfing Lynne Fuston’s site:
Mark Levinson astonished Forum attendees with the revelation that the PCM recording system that is currently used for our CDs, DVDs, television, and cell phones has a negative effect on the body-and that, in addition to the extraordinary improvement in high fidelity, one bit technology has a very positive physical effect. With a demonstration utilizing kinesiology techniques to identify factors which block the body’s natural healing processes and show weaknesses through pressure point testing of muscle strength, Levinson put forth a compelling case.
In a “blind” test on several audience members selected at random, PCM elicited an across-the-board negative response, indicating high stress levels, while response to Super DVD was overwhelmingly positive. Geoffrey Fushi commented: “When Mark did his tests, a shock wave went through the audience. I hope that the recording industry will make a decision to drop PCM and transition to one bit technology-both for the amazing high fidelity and postive phyical effect, and the potential boom in sales as public enthusiasm gains momentum.”
Mark Levinson is an interesting character and a legend in the high-end audiophile community. I find it very odd though that PCM would have a negative impact on the body. I rarely listen to PCM when I play CDs, DVDs, etc. More often than not I prefer to listen to speakers. Last time I checked my speakers were not pushing air one bit at a time. But why let such matters interfere with a good story.
I took a look at one of Mark Levinson’s products, a $6,700 USD CD processor, called the No. 390s. This modestly priced CD processor uses the Analog Devices AD1853 DAC which offers the following attributes:
The AD1853 is the first audio DAC to support the 192 kHz Sample Rate now included in the DVD-Audio specification. The AD1853 is fully compatible with sample rate from 32 kHz up to and including 192 kHz. It also achieves 120 dB Dynamic Range and Signal-to-Noise Ratio without muting and 107 dB THD+N.
The AD1853 also features a superior Digital Filter with 115 dB stop-band-attenuation. The AD1853 uses Analog Devices’ exclusive Multibit Sigma-Delta Modulator with “Perfect Differential Linearity” for reduced idle tones. It also features Analog’s patented Data Directed Scrambling to minimize sensitivity to jitter. The AD1853 also includes a click-less on-chip volume control.
Well, this is bad! The Mark Levinson CD Processor uses a multibit sigma-delta modulator. What’s worse is Mark’s perspective on CD players, even those he tries to sell at $6,700 USD:
We have learned that no matter how much money is spent on CD players and CD-based systems, the results are never truly satisfying.
I’m glad I didn’t buy this CD player after all. Not only does it sound bad but it would have made me sick. My iPod works fine though because I always feel great when I listen to it. MP3 files stream one bit at a time.
I am doing final mixes for one project right now and I am also starting final mixes on another project in a few weeks time. Like many others in our field I am starting to lose the thread of all the changes that can occur to a project as it goes through its life. This is due, in part, to the volatile nature of the recording process today. Unlike 20 years ago, where it was very clear what constituted professional recording, we now have an amazing array of technologies, delivery formats and widely ranging engineering skills. So just what do you deliver your finals on these days? And how do you document your finals? In most cases the record companies still dictate these terms.
The P&E wing of the Recording Academy created the Delivery Recommendations for Master Recordings as a specification for transitional and archival storage of master recordings. You can find the full recommendation here. I had a few of my friends participate in the committee.
One item of interest is the need to ensure that each track should be “flattened” as a continuous Broadcast Wave File without processing or automation. In audio engineering we often slice discrete audio tracks into fragments. I have come across many projects where the original track is completely lost. All that is left is the edited and processed track. The original performance is gone forever!
I was catching up on the news at the Canadian Recording Industry Association site and I came across this staggering piece of information:
The Tragically Hip, one of Canada’s treasured cultural assets, was one of the hardest hit [by illegal downloads]. During a five-week stretch from 30 March to 7 May, there were more than half a million unauthorized attempts to download the new Tragically Hip single, “Vaccination Scar”. Overall, during this period, Universal Music reported 2.8 million attempts to illegally download The Tragically Hip’s recordings. During the same period fewer than 1,000 copies were purchased legally online.
The article goes on to quote several Canadian artists about their concern over the massive amount of downloading that is taking place on the Internet. Jann Arden makes a compelling argument in the same article:
Downloading music from the Internet is ironically the hope, and alarmingly the impending decay and destruction, of the music industry. Unless these downloads are monitored and artists are compensated for their work, there will be NO work to download. None of us, as writers and performers, can afford to keep making the music that has always, and will always, make the world a little easier to swallow in troubled times. We cannot play if we are not paid. Illegal downloads must be halted and those offenders punished in a court of law. This issue is very serious and should be given much more respect and attention than it has received in this country.
CRIA reports that the Canadian music industry has experienced retail sales losses of in excess of $465 million since 1999, as well as staff layoffs of 25 per cent and more in the industry over the past year. More than 45,000 individuals are directly or indirectly dependent upon the health of the recording industry in Canada, including those in songwriting, recording studios, manufacturing, retailing, broadcasting, music publishing, concert promotion, management and many other primary and support services.
Something to think about if you are tempted to illegally download music.
Check out the debate at Crooked Timber. I’m pretty sure that this isn’t what Jesus would do. It appears that James Dobson’s socially conservative activist group, Focus on the Family, has included Michael Moore’s home address in their daily email to supporters sent out sometime last week. I have no idea whether this is true or not however there is quite the debate on Crooked Timber’s blog on the merits of such an action by a Christian organization.
An Adamson Yaxis Y10 line array was recently installed at the Prayer Palace Ministries in Toronto, Ontario. Designed as an audio system re-fit, the Yaxis system is comprised of 16 Adamson Y10 cabinets, with four SpekTrix enclosures used as a centre cluster.
The Prayer Palace is one of the largest houses of worship in North America, with an octagonal-shaped sanctuary encompassing approximately 38,000 square feet. It is the first church to use Adamson’s new SpekTrix, an ultra-compact, true 3-way line array, in a permanent audio system install.
“The Prayer Palace Ministries hold two regular Sunday masses in this space, which doubles as a sanctuary and a 4,500-seat auditorium capable of hosting a variety of other secular and ethnic events,” said Chris Mathany, Technical Services Director for Sound Plus Show Systems of Concord, Ontario, who completed the installation.
Although Concord is not too far from where I live I have not had a chance to visit this facility although I would like to learn more about what they have been doing with their sound system. There was an article on this installation in Professional Sound magazine. I would like to hear the sound system. I’ve attached a photo of part of the line array. Looks impressive.
I was wandering through the Mackie forum last night to see if there was any report on crosstalk issues with the SR consoles. I came across this post:
I ordered a Mackie desk, because of the reputation, and the fact it was assembled in the USA, thats why I was prepared to pay the high price. (I could have got a Chinese Behringer for half the price)
Imagine my surprise when it arrived and I found that it is ‘Designed by Mackoids in Woodinville, WA, USA – Manufactured in Malaysia’
I would imagine this is to ‘Reduce manufacturing costs’, so when I ordered my American desk at the agreed price was it priced at a loss due to the high costs in the USA or are Mackie ensuring higher returns by farming out their construction?
I have no problem with goods being assembled in different countries (except China, human rights doncha know), but I would like to be made aware of the fact – and pay accordingly.
You can read all the gory details of the business mess that is Loud Technologies (they have the Mackie brand now) here. Some interesting tidbits: accumulated deficit of $37 million, net sales decreased by 21% over last year, layoffs, reduction in research and development. More interesting perhaps is the closing of the manufacturing facility in Woodinville Washington to outsource manufacturing of products offshore. So… premium pricing and cheap manufacturing go hand in hand when a company is in this much difficulty. Quality? If you are concerned about quality best to look elsewhere.
Little wonder Mackie has gone through such financial difficulties over the past few years. Mackie is a company that markets aggressively and convinces the novice that they can offer exceptional sonic quality at value prices. In reality, Mackie offers premium priced cheap products. At least Behringer aligns the price/quality curves. Cheap products sold for a cheap price.
I am whining about Mackie because I have to use one of their consoles every week for live sound. I do not expect the Mackie to sound as good as my Neve. I do not expect it to offer the same level of functionality. But I do expect some basic performance attributes for the price point. I would gladly use Allen & Heath or Soundcraft products over the Mackie at similar price points. I was not at the church when this purchase decision was made.
The board in question, an SR32-4, has significant crosstalk issues through the aux sends. I often have CDs or MP3s on constant rotation and simply mute the channel when I don’t require the background music. No latency in terms of pressing the play button and when the church service ends it adds a nice touch to have the music already cued and good to go. However, even though the channel is muted, a small amount of the signal is routed to the master aux sends even though no signal is being directed to the auxes from the channel. This means that a noticeable signal arrives to the monitors on stage. How irritating.
I also don’t like the 60mm faders. They have a terrible feel and a short throw. The paint on the scribble strip is easily removed by masking tape. The board only offers 6 aux sends. There is no direct out. The XLR main outs have a +6db boost. I had to use the alternate TRS outs to connect to a loudspeaker management system. The EQ is brittle to my ear.
I would never recommend a Mackie. Too many compromises on sonic quality for the price. Better sounding products are available at competitive price levels. As for Behringer… don’t get me started on that company 😉
Decided that it was time for a new look to the blog. I elected to charge ahead with Cascading Style Sheets (CSS) and present the blog without using any HTML tables. The easiest tutorial I found on setting up a three column layout using CSS was here. After the first release I decided that I wanted to move to two columns. I’m not sure about the bluish green colours so I may change that later. There may be a few wrinkles in this blog as I troubleshoot the odds and ends of a major redesign.